Streamlined Technical Evaluations

Hello All!

I am wondering if anybody has experience implementing the PIL (procurement innovation lab) streamlined procedures for technical evaluations.  I am interested in your best practices lessons learned for implementing confidence ratings for technical factor, where technical is significantly more important than price.  What was your approach for documenting the consensus report and confidence levels.

With regard to evaluation under the mission suitability and technical/management factors, the solicitation stated that the agency “will consider the Offeror’s approach and the risks associated with the approaches proposed,” and make “confidence assessments” regarding the offeror’s understanding of the requirements and the likelihood of successful contract performance, assigning ratings under each factor of: high confidence, some confidence, or low confidence.